Friday, August 22, 2025

"5-4-3-2-1"

Last night, I figured out the chords for "5-4-3-2-1," and while I was thinking about the song again to-day, I discovered a small feature in it:  the line "Down the valley on their horses they thundered" is sung to a descending melody (the pitches are F Eb C Bb Ab), musically illustrating this "down."

Sunday, July 20, 2025

"Machines"

I recently listened to Live at the BBC 64-66 and noticed some elements in "Machines" that match the lyrics.  Throughout the song, there's a ratcheting noise (I think this is approximated by a percussive sound on muted guitar strings in the live version).  The constancy of this sound matches the "keep right on" in the initial lines of most of the verses:  "Machines, machines, they keep right on movin'," "Machines, machines, they keep right on goin'," and "Machines, machines, they keep right on winning."

Additionally, this persistency contrasts with the human limitations of the narrator, who must take breaks, not only in physical labor ("I've got to find a place to rest my head") but also in simply creating a sound ("But I am weak... Too tired to speak..."), demonstrated by the pauses between lines that are necessary in order to breathe.

In comparing the live and studio versions, I also discovered that some of the lyrics in the second verse differ considerably.  Where the studio version has
I've got to find a place to rest my head
Machine, he smile at me and say, "I'm gonna be your bed"
the live version has
But I'm flesh and blood, and hard as I may try
If I got to keep workin' them machines, I know I'm gonna die

Wednesday, June 25, 2025

"So Long, Dad"

I was thinking about "So Long, Dad" yester-day and discovered an ambiguity in the lyrics.  One line could be written as either "Just drop by when it's convenient to" or "Just drop by when it's convenient, too."  The meaning isn't affected very much because in either rendering, "to[o]" isn't essential and really just sets up the rhyme for the following line, which Manfred draws particular attention to in an interview on Live at the BBC 66-69:  "Be sure to call before you do."

"To" is actually sort of redundant since it merely indicates an ellipsis of the repeated verb:  "Just drop by when it's convenient to [drop by]."

Friday, May 23, 2025

"Ha! Ha! Said the Clown"

In the line "Is it bringing you down that you've lost your chance" in "Ha! Ha! Said the Clown," the phrase "bringing you down" is sung to a descending group of notes (spanning nearly an octave:  D C# B E), musically illustrating the meaning.

Thursday, May 22, 2025

"Each and Every Day"

I listened to Mighty Garvey! recently and noticed some small features.

In the title line of "Each and Every Day," the phrase "ev'ry day" is sung to notes of all different pitches (A C D), giving a sense of number.

I have some more significant comments about the line "There's no doubt about; she can't do without my love" (although maybe it should be formatted as two lines:  "There's no doubt about / She can't do without my love").  Poetically, "there's no doubt about" and "she can't do without" complement each other since they have the same number of syllables and they rhyme.  (There are even short rests after each line as if to point out this balance.)  Semantically, though, "she can't do without" is incomplete.  It needs "my love" to finish the sense, and this grammatical sort of dependence matches the meaning.  In a way, this is the opposite of what I noted years ago in the lines "Got a feelin' goin' for each other, yeah / I could never leave her for another girl," where "girl" isn't necessary in terms of syllable count or semantic completion.

Sunday, March 16, 2025

"My Name Is Jack"

Yester-day, I listened to the first disc of Live at the BBC 66-69, and I noticed a small feature in "My Name Is Jack" (also true of the studio recording):  multiple voices sing the second half of the chorus ("We all love Jack..."), so there's an audible representation of that "all."